Controversy Over AI-Driven Surgery Waitlist Prioritization in New Zealand

Thumbnail Image

The information displayed in the AIM should not be reported as representing the official views of the OECD or of its member countries.

New Zealand hospitals have implemented an algorithm to prioritize elective surgery waitlists, factoring in clinical need, wait time, location, financial status, and ethnicity. The system gives higher priority to Māori and Pacific patients to address historic inequities, sparking political and ethical debate over potential discrimination and fairness in healthcare access.[AI generated]

Why's our monitor labelling this an incident or hazard?

An AI system (the equity adjustor algorithm) is explicitly described as being used to determine surgery waitlist priority, directly influencing patient treatment timing. This use affects human rights and equity in healthcare, which falls under violations or breaches of obligations intended to protect fundamental rights. The system's deployment has real-world effects on patient access and outcomes, thus constituting an AI Incident. Although the intent is to reduce harm, the system's role in prioritizing patients based on ethnicity is a direct factor in differential treatment, meeting the criteria for an AI Incident rather than a hazard or complementary information.[AI generated]
AI principles
FairnessRespect of human rights

Industries
Healthcare, drugs, and biotechnology

Affected stakeholders
Consumers

Harm types
Human or fundamental rights

Business function:
Other

AI system task:
Goal-driven organisation


Articles about this incident or hazard